Graphics File Formats FAQ (Part 4 of 4): Tips and Tricks of the Trade

From: jdm@ora.com
Newsgroups: comp.graphics.misc,comp.answers,news.answers
Subject: Graphics File Formats FAQ (Part 4 of 4): Tips and Tricks of the Trade
Supersedes: <graphics/fileformats-faq-4-849730784@ora.com>
Followup-To: poster
Date: 20 Jan 1997 00:13:12 -0800
Organization: O'Reilly & Associates, Inc.
Sender: jdm@ruby.ora.com
Expires: 02/24/97 00:13:00
Message-ID: <graphics/fileformats-faq-4-853747980@ora.com>
References: <graphics/fileformats-faq-1-853747980@ora.com>
Reply-To: jdm@ora.com (James D. Murray)
Summary: This document answers many of the most frequently asked 
        questions about graphics file formats on Usenet.
Keywords: FAQ, GRAPHICS, FORMAT, IMAGE, MULTIMEDIA, 3D

Posted-By: auto-faq 3.1.1.2
Archive-name: graphics/fileformats-faq/part4
Posting-Frequency: monthly
Last-modified: 20Jan97

Graphics File Formats FAQ (Part 4 of 4): Tips and Tricks of the Trade

------------------------------

This FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions) list contains information on
graphics file formats, including, raster, vector, metafile, Page
Description Language, 3D object, animation, and multimedia formats.

This FAQ is divided into four parts, each covering a different area of
graphics file format information:

  Graphics File Formats FAQ (Part 1 of 4): General Graphics Format Questions
  Graphics File Formats FAQ (Part 2 of 4): Image Conversion and Display Programs
  Graphics File Formats FAQ (Part 3 of 4): Where to Get File Format Specifications
  Graphics File Formats FAQ (Part 4 of 4): Tips and Tricks of the Trade

Please email contributions, corrections, and suggestions about this FAQ to
jdm@ora.com. Relevant information posted to newsgroups will not
automatically make it into this FAQ.

-- James D. Murray

------------------------------

Subject: 0. Contents of Tips and Tricks of the Trade 
Subjects marked with <NEW> are new to this FAQ. Subjects marked with <UPD>
have been updated since the last release  of this FAQ.

I. General questions about this FAQ

0. Maintainer's Comments
1. What's new in this latest FAQ release?

II. Programming Tips for Graphics File Formats

0. What's the best way to read a file header?
1. What's this business about endianness?
2. How can I determine the byte-order of a system at run-time?
3. How can I identify the format of a graphics file?
4. What are the format identifiers of some popular file formats?

III. Kudos and Assertions

0. Acknowledgments
1. About The Author
2. Disclaimer
3. Copyright Notice


------------------------------


Subject: I. General questions about this FAQ 

------------------------------

Subject: 0. Maintainer's Comments

Programmer's are code-hungry people. They just want the secrets and they want
them to work NOW! But always in the back of a hack's mind there are the
questions: "Is this really the best way to do this? Could it be better?".

This FAQ is to share ideas on the implementation details of reading, writing,
converting, and displaying graphics file formats. You'll probably get some
good ideas here, find a few things you didn't know about, and even have a few
suggestions and improvements of you own to add (send them to jdm@ora.com).

If you need to know the best way to do something with file formats, or
just find it embarrassing to implement a chunk of some other programmer's
code and then have to admit you really don't understand how it works, then
this FAQ is for you.

------------------------------

Subject: 1. What's new in this latest FAQ release?

  o Minor bug fixed in GetLittleWord() and GetLittleDword() functions

------------------------------

Subject: II. Programming Tips for Graphics File Formats 

------------------------------

Subject: 0. What's the best way to read a file header?

You wouldn't think there's a lot of mystery about reading a few bytes from
a disk file, eh? Programmer's, however, are constantly loosing time
because they don't consider a few problems that may occur and cause them
to loose time. Consider the following code:

  typedef struct _Header
  {
    BYTE Id;
    WORD Height;
    WORD Width;
    BYTE Colors;
  } HEADER;

  HEADER Header;

  void ReadHeader(FILE *fp)
  {
    if (fp != (FILE *)NULL)
      fread(&Header, sizeof(HEADER), 1, fp);
  }

Looks good, right? The fread() will read the next sizeof(HEADER) bytes from
a valid FILE pointer into the Header data structure. So what could go
wrong?

The problem often encountered with this method is one of element alignment
within structures. Compilers may pad structures with "invisible" elements
to allow each "visible" element to align on a 2- or 4-byte address
boundary.  This is done for efficiency in accessing the element while in
memory. Padding may also be added to the end of the structure to bring
it's total length to an even number of bytes. This is done so the data
following the structure in memory will also align on a proper address
boundary.

If the above code is compiled with no (or 1-byte) structure alignment the
code will operate as expected. With 2-byte alignment an extra two bytes
would be added to the HEADER structure in memory and make it appear as
such:

  typedef struct _Header
  {
    BYTE Id;
    BYTE Pad1;      // Added padding
    WORD Height;
    WORD Width;
    BYTE Colors;
    BYTE Pad2;      // Added padding
  } HEADER;

As you can see the fread() will store the correct value in Id, but the
first byte of Height will be stored in the padding byte. This will throw
off the correct storage of data in the remaining part of the structure
causing the values to be garbage.

A compiler using 4-byte alignment would change the HEADER in memory as such:

  typedef struct _Header
  {
    BYTE Id;
    BYTE Pad1;      // Added padding
    BYTE Pad2;      // Added padding
    BYTE Pad3;      // Added padding
    WORD Height;
    WORD Width;
    BYTE Colors;
    BYTE Pad4;      // Added padding
    BYTE Pad5;      // Added padding
    BYTE Pad6;      // Added padding
  } HEADER;

What started off as a 6-byte header increased to 8 and 12 bytes thanks to
alignment. But what can you do? All the documentation and makefiles you
write will not prevent someone from compiling with the wrong options flag
and then pulling their (or your) hair out when your software appears not
to work correctly.

Now considering this alternative to the ReadHeader() function:

  HEADER Header;

  void ReadHeader(FILE *fp)
  {
    if (fp != (FILE *)NULL)
    {
      fread(&Header.Id, sizeof(Header.Id), 1, fp);
      fread(&Header.Height, sizeof(Header.Height), 1, fp);
      fread(&Header.Width, sizeof(Header.Width), 1, fp);
      fread(&Header.Colors, sizeof(Header.Colors), 1, fp);
    }
  }

What both you and your compiler now see is a lot more code. Rather than
reading the entire structure in one, elegant shot, you read in each
element separately using multiple calls to fread(). The trade-off here is
increased code size for not caring what the structure alignment option of
the compiler is set to. These cases are also true for writing structures
to files using fwrite(). Write only the data and not the padding please.

But is there still anything we've yet over looked? Will fread() (fscanf(),
fgetc(), and so forth) always return the data we expect?  Will fwrite()
(fprintf(), fputc(), and so forth) ever write data that we don't want, or
in a way we don't expect? Read on to the next section...

------------------------------

Subject: 1. What's this business about endianness?

So you've been pulling you hair out trying to discover why your elegant
and perfect-beyond-reproach code, running on your Macintosh or Sun, is
reading garbage from PCX and TGA files. Or perhaps your MS-DOS or Windows
application just can't seem to make heads or tails out of that Sun Raster
file. And, to make matters even more mysterious, it seems your most
illustrious creation will read some TIFF files, but not others.

As was hinted at in the previous section, just reading the header of a
graphics file one field is not enough to insure data is always read correctly
(not enough for portable code, anyway). In addition to structure, we must also
consider the endianness of the file's data, and the endianness of the
system's architecture our code is running on.

Here's are some baseline rules to follow:

  1) Graphics files typically use a fixed byte-ordering scheme. For example, 
     PCX and TGA files are always little-endian; Sun Raster and Macintosh
     PICT are always big-endian.
  2) Graphics files that may contain data using either byte-ordering scheme
     (for example TIFF) will have an identifier that indicates the
     endianness of the data.
  3) ASCII-based graphics files (such as DXF and most 3D object files),
     have no endianness and are always read in the same way on any system.
  4) Most CPUs use a fixed byte-ordering scheme. For example, the 80486
     is little-endian and the 68040 is big-endian.
  5) You can test for the type of endianness a system using software.
  6) There are many systems that are neither big- nor little-endian; these
     middle-endian systems will possibly cause such byte-order detection
     tests to return erroneous results.

Now we know that using fread() on a big-endian system to read data from a
file that was originally written in little-endian order will return
incorrect data. Actually, the data is correct, but the bytes that make up
the data are arranged in the wrong order. If we attempt to read the 16-bit
value 1234h from a little-endian file, it would be stored in memory using
the big-endian byte-ordering scheme and the value 3412h would result. What
we need is a swap function to change the resulting position of the bytes:

  WORD SwapTwoBytes(WORD w)
  {
      register WORD tmp;
      tmp =  (w & 0x00FF);
      tmp = ((w & 0xFF00) >> 0x08) | (tmp << 0x08);
      return(tmp);
  }
  
Now we can read a two-byte header value and swap the bytes as such:

  fread(&Header.Height, sizeof(Header.Height), 1, fp);
  Header.Height = SwapTwoBytes(Header.Height);

But what about four-byte values? The value 12345678h would be stored as
78563412h. What we need is a swap function to handle four-byte values:

  DWORD SwapFourBytes(DWORD dw)
  {
      register DWORD tmp;
      tmp =  (dw & 0x000000FF);
      tmp = ((dw & 0x0000FF00) >> 0x08) | (tmp << 0x08);
      tmp = ((dw & 0x00FF0000) >> 0x10) | (tmp << 0x08);
      tmp = ((dw & 0xFF000000) >> 0x18) | (tmp << 0x08);
      return(tmp);
  }

But how do we know when to swap and when not to swap? We always know the
byte-order of a graphics file that we are reading, but how do we check
what the endianness of system we are running on is? Using the C language,
we might use preprocessor switches to cause a conditional compile based on
a system definition flag:

  #define MSDOS     1
  #define WINDOWS   2
  #define MACINTOSH 3
  #define AMIGA     4
  #define SUNUNIX   5
  
  #define SYSTEM    MSDOS
  
  #if defined(SYSTEM == MSDOS)  
    // Little-endian code here
  #elif defined(SYSTEM == WINDOWS)  
    // Little-endian code here
  #elif defined(SYSTEM == MACINTOSH)  
    // Big-endian code here
  #elif defined(SYSTEM == AMIGA)  
    // Big-endian code here
  #elif defined(SYSTEM == SUNUNIX)  
    // Big-endian code here
  #else
  #error Unknown SYSTEM definition
  #endif

My reaction to the above code was *YUCK!* (and I hope yours was too!).  A
snarl of fread(), fwrite(), SwapTwoBytes(), and SwapFourBytes() functions
laced between preprocessor statements is hardly elegant code, although
sometimes it is our best choice. Fortunately, this is not one of those
times.

What we first need is a set of functions to read the data from a file
using the byte-ordering scheme of the data. This effectively combines the
read\write and swap operations into one set of functions. Considering the
following:

  WORD GetBigWord(FILE *fp)
  {
      register WORD w;
      w =  (WORD) (fgetc(fp) & 0xFF);
      w = ((WORD) (fgetc(fp) & 0xFF)) | (w << 0x08);
      return(w);
  }
  
  WORD GetLittleWord(FILE *fp)
  {
      register WORD w;
      w =  (WORD) (fgetc(fp) & 0xFF);
      w |= ((WORD) (fgetc(fp) & 0xFF) << 0x08);
      return(w);
  }
  
  DWORD GetBigDoubleWord(FILE *fp)
  {
      register DWORD dw;
      dw =  (DWORD) (fgetc(fp) & 0xFF);
      dw = ((DWORD) (fgetc(fp) & 0xFF)) | (dw << 0x08);
      dw = ((DWORD) (fgetc(fp) & 0xFF)) | (dw << 0x08);
      dw = ((DWORD) (fgetc(fp) & 0xFF)) | (dw << 0x08);
      return(dw);
  }
  
  DWORD GetLittleDoubleWord(FILE *fp)
  {
      register DWORD dw;
      dw =  (DWORD) (fgetc(fp) & 0xFF);
      dw |= ((DWORD) (fgetc(fp) & 0xFF) << 0x08);
      dw |= ((DWORD) (fgetc(fp) & 0xFF) << 0x10);
      dw |= ((DWORD) (fgetc(fp) & 0xFF) << 0x18);
      return(dw);
  }
  
  void PutBigWord(WORD w, FILE *fp)
  {
      fputc((w >> 0x08) & 0xFF, fp);
      fputc(w & 0xFF, fp);
  }
  
  void PutLittleWord(WORD w, FILE *fp)
  {
      fputc(w & 0xFF, fp);
      fputc((w >> 0x08) & 0xFF, fp);
  }
  
  void PutBigDoubleWord(DWORD dw, FILE *fp)
  {
      fputc((dw >> 0x18) & 0xFF, fp);
      fputc((dw >> 0x10) & 0xFF, fp);
      fputc((dw >> 0x08) & 0xFF, fp);
      fputc(dw & 0xFF, fp);
  }
  
  void PutLittleDoubleWord(DWORD dw, FILE *fp)
  {
      fputc(dw & 0xFF, fp);
      fputc((dw >> 0x08) & 0xFF, fp);
      fputc((dw >> 0x10) & 0xFF, fp);
      fputc((dw >> 0x18) & 0xFF, fp);
  }

If we were reading a little-endian file on a big-endian system (or visa
versa), the previous code:

  fread(&Header.Height, sizeof(Header.Height), 1, fp);
  Header.Height = SwapTwoBytes(Header.Height);

Would be replaced by:
  
  Header.Height = GetLittleWord(fp);

The code to write the same value to a file would be changed from:

  Header.Height = SwapTwoBytes(Header.Height);
  fwrite(&Header.Height, sizeof(Header.Height), 1, fp);

To the slightly more readable:

  PutLittleWord(Header.Height, fp);

Note that these functions are the same regardless of the endianness of a
system. For example, the ReadLittleWord() will always read a two-byte value
from a little-endian file regardless of the endianness of the system;
PutBigDoubleWord() will always write a four-byte big-endian value, and so
forth.

------------------------------

Subject: 2. How can I determine the byte-order of a system at run-time?

You may wish to optimize how you read (or write) data from a graphics file
based on the endianness of your system. Using the GetBigDoubleWord()
function mentioned in the previous section to read big-endian data from a
file on a big-endian system imposes extra overhead we don't really need
(although if the actual number of read/write operations in your program is
small you might not consider this overhead to be too bad).

If our code could tell what the endianness of the system was at run-time,
it could choose (using function pointers) what set of read/write functions
to use. Look at the following function:

  #define BIG_ENDIAN      0
  #define LITTLE_ENDIAN   1

  int TestByteOrder(void)
  {
      short int word = 0x0001;
      char *byte = (char *) &word;
      return(byte[0] ? LITTLE_ENDIAN : BIG_ENDIAN);
  }

This code assigns the value 0001h to a 16-bit integer. A char pointer is
then assigned to point at the first (least-significant) byte of the
integer value.  If the first byte of the integer is 01h, then the system
is little-endian (the 01h is in the lowest, or least-significant,
address). If it is 00h then the system is big-endian.

------------------------------

Subject: 3. How can I identify the format of a graphics file?

When writing any type of file or data stream reader it is very important
to implement some sort of method for verifying that the input data is in
the format you expect. Here are a few methods:

1) Trust the user of your program to always supply the correct data,
thereby freeing you from the tedious task of writing any type of format
identification routines. Choose this method and you will provide solid
proof that contradicts the popular claim that users are inherently far
more stupid than programmers.

2) Read the file extension or descriptor. A GIF file will always have the
extension .GIF, right? Targa files .TGA, yes?  And TIFF files will have an
extension of .TIF or a descriptor of TIFF. So no problem?

Well, for the most part, this is true. This method certainly isn't
bulletproof, however.  Your reader will occasionally be fed the odd-batch
of mis-label files ("I thought they were PCX files!"). Or files with
unrecognized mangled extensions  (.TAR rather than .TGA or .JFI rather
than .JPG) that your reader knows how to read, but won't read because it
doesn't recognize the extensions. File extensions also won't usually tell
you the revision of the file format you are reading (with some revisions
creating an almost entirely new format). And more than one file format
share the more common file extensions (such as .IMG and .PIC). And last of
all, data streams have no file extensions or descriptors to read at all.

3) Read the file and attempt to recognize the format by specific patterns
in the data. Most file formats contain some sort of identifying pattern of
data that is identical in all files. In some cases this pattern gives and
indication of the revision of the format (such as GIF87a and GIF89a) or
the endianness of the data format.

Nothing is easy, however. Not all formats contain such identifiers (such
as PCX). And those that do don't necessarily put it at the beginning of
the file. This means if the data is in the format of a stream you many
have to read (and buffer) most or all of the data before you can determine
the format. Of course, not all graphics formats are suitable to be read as
a data stream anyway.

Your best bet for a method of format detection is a combination of methods
two and three. First believe the file extension or descriptor, read some
data, and check for identifying data patterns. If this test fails, then
attempt to recognize all other known patterns.

Run-time file format identification a black-art at best.

------------------------------

Subject: 4. What are the format identifiers of some popular file formats?

Here are a few algorithms that you can use to determine the format of a
graphics file at run-time.


GIF: The first six bytes of a GIF file will be the byte pattern of 
     474946383761h ("GIF87a") or 474946383961h ("GIF89a").

JFIF: The first three bytes are ffd8ffh (i.e., an SOI marker followed
      by any marker). Do not check the fourth byte, as it will vary.

JPEG: The first three bytes are ffd8ffh (i.e., an SOI marker followed
      by any marker). Do not check the fourth byte, as it will vary.
      This works with most variants of "raw JPEG" as well.

PNG: The first eight bytes of all PNG files are 89504e470d0a1a0ah.

SPIFF: The first three bytes are ffd8ffh (i.e., an SOI marker followed
       by any marker). Do not check the fourth byte, as it will vary.

Sun: The first four bytes of a Sun Rasterfile are 59a66a95h. If you have
     accidentally read this identifier using the little-endian byte order
     this value will will be read as 956aa659h.

TGA: The last 18 bytes of a TGA Version 2 file is the string
     "TRUEVISION-XFILE.\0". If this string is not present, then the file
     is assumed to be a TGA Version 1 file.

TIFF: The first four bytes of a big-endian TIFF files are 4d4d002ah and
      49492a00h for little-endian TIFF files.

------------------------------

Subject: III. Kudos and Assertions 

------------------------------

Subject: 0. Acknowledgments

  Chris M. Cooney <cooney1@imssys.imssys.com>
  Tom Lane <tgl@netcom.com>
  Charles R. Patton <crpatton@ingr.com>

------------------------------

Subject: 1. About The Author

The author of this FAQ, James D. Murray, lives in the City of Orange,
Orange County, California, USA. He is the co-author of the book
Encyclopedia of Graphics File Formats published by O'Reilly and
Associates, makes a living writing books for O'Reilly, writing
telecommuncations network management software in C++ and Visual Basic,
and may be reached as jdm@ora.com,
or via U.S. Snail at: P.O. Box 70, Orange, CA 92666-0070 USA.

------------------------------

Subject: 2. Disclaimer

While every effort has been taken to insure the accuracy of the
information contained in this FAQ list compilation, the author and
contributors assume no responsibility for errors or omissions, or for
damages resulting from the use of the information contained herein.

------------------------------

Subject: 3. Copyright Notice

This FAQ is Copyright 1994-96 by James D. Murray. This work may be
reproduced, in whole or in part, using any medium, including, but not
limited to, electronic transmission, CD-ROM, or published in print, under
the condition that this copyright notice remains intact.

------------------------------